India

Grandmother and Granddaughter’s Claim of Missing Gold from Hyderabad Locker Rejected by Consumer Commission

By

Grandmother and Granddaughter’s Claim of Missing Gold from Hyderabad Locker Rejected by Consumer Commission

A 79‑year‑old grandmother and her granddaughter claimed that gold coins, bars and melted gold had disappeared from their safe deposit locker at SBI’s Gunfoundry branch in Hyderabad. They alleged that they had deposited jewellery, pure gold coins, gold bars and approximately 200 grams of melted gold in the locker in 2015, and that a photograph of the items had been taken. In 2016 the granddaughter, who was then in Canada, visited the branch to collect the jewellery and found that eight pure gold coins, two gold bars and some melted gold were missing. The complainants reported the matter to the branch manager, then approached the police, and a case was registered under Section 380 of the Indian Penal Code. The police classified the case as “undetectable.” The complainants filed a protest petition against the police closure, which was still pending when the Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission delivered its decision on 2 September 2026.

The commission held that the evidence presented was insufficient to establish the bank’s liability. It examined the photograph and a CD submitted by the complainants and found that the image showed two large gold bars and a coin inside a plastic pouch but was undated and unsigned. The commission stated that without corroborating evidence that the items had been deposited in the locker before the alleged loss, the photograph could not be used to prove the claim. No evidence was produced that the locker’s personal lock had been damaged or that the locker had been forcibly opened. The police classification of the case as undetectable was considered but did not prove that the gold had never been stored in the locker.

The commission also reviewed Reserve Bank of India guidelines for safe deposit lockers, which require banks to exercise due care and maintain proper documentation. It explained that the relationship between a bank and a locker holder is that of a lessor and hirer, and that bank employees are generally not present when customers access their lockers, so they cannot verify the contents.

Citing a 2019 National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission ruling, the commission concluded that the complainants’ claim of theft due to negligence could not be upheld without supporting evidence. Consequently, it rejected the appeal, upheld the District Commission’s decision, and did not impose any costs. The complainants were allowed to pursue their pending protest petition and seek other legal remedies.

Frequently asked questions

What was the outcome of the consumer commission's decision?

The commission rejected the appeal, upheld the District Commission’s decision, and did not impose any costs.

Why did the commission find the evidence insufficient?

The photograph was undated and unsigned, showed only two large gold bars and a coin inside a plastic pouch, and lacked corroborating evidence that the items were deposited before the alleged loss; no evidence of lock damage or forced opening was produced.

Related stories