Politics

Burnham Criticises Brexit as a Net Loss Ahead of EU Summit

By

Burnham Criticises Brexit as a Net Loss Ahead of EU Summit

Prime Minister Andy Burnham said on Monday that the United Kingdom has lost more than it has gained from leaving the European Union. Speaking at the Lord Mayor's Banquet, he compared the Brexit deal to the "emperor's new clothes", arguing that a "needlessly hard Brexit" has created barriers for businesses and that the promise to "take back control" has not been delivered.

Burnham will sign new agreements on food, energy and youth mobility with the EU at the summit on Friday, after the substance of those deals was set by his predecessor, Sir Keir Starmer. He said that following the summit he would begin new discussions with the EU about options for "our long‑term relationship", but warned it would take time and that "at every stage the British people will be the boss". He has ruled out major changes before the next general election.

In his first major foreign‑policy speech, Burnham set out three tests for any agreement. First, it must be consistent with Labour’s 2024 manifesto pledge that there would be "no return to the single market, the customs union or freedom of movement". Second, it must improve the original Brexit deal and bring it closer to what voters thought they were voting for in 2016. Third, it must pass the "Makerfield test" of providing tangible improvements to people’s everyday lives, a reference to voters in his Greater Manchester constituency.

Burnham described the prospect of a new deal as a "win‑win" and a "new approach" that is not adversarial, does not burn bridges, but is constructive and positive. He said Britain would be "back in the game in a big way" and would "lead with its values".

The summit will see the UK seek further changes to the deal struck in May 2025, covering fishing, trade and other areas. A draft deal on removing post‑Brexit checks from food and agriculture exports has been agreed ahead of the meeting, which the government says will cut costs for businesses and could lower prices for shoppers. Critics argue the deal will make the UK a "rule taker" from Brussels, aligning with EU regulations without being able to vote on them. Similar texts for emissions trading and a youth travel and work scheme have also been circulated to EU nations.

Burnham, who was elected to Parliament in the Makerfield by‑election that propelled his return, had promised not to "re‑run" Brexit arguments when he was a candidate. Since becoming prime minister he has said he wants to explore a different long‑term relationship with the bloc, suggesting options ranging from no changes to rejoining the customs union, the single market or a fresh referendum on full EU membership. He has stressed that any changes would require a mandate from the public at a general election.

Former Prime Minister Boris Johnson has warned Burnham against "wasting his premiership" on Europe, saying it is madness to make Brexit a political priority. Conservative deputy leader Alex Burghart accused Burnham of reopening a debate the country settled long ago. Reform UK, the Liberal Democrats and the Green Party have all expressed opposition to any form of alignment that would bind the UK to EU rules.

The summit is scheduled for Friday, with the UK and EU expected to finalise details of the agreements.

Frequently asked questions

What new agreements will Prime Minister Andy Burnham sign with the EU at the upcoming summit?

He will sign new agreements on food, energy and youth mobility with the EU.

What are the three tests that Burnham set for any future agreement with the EU?

The agreement must be consistent with Labour’s 2024 manifesto pledge of no return to the single market, customs union or freedom of movement; it must improve the original Brexit deal and bring it closer to voters’ 2016 expectations; and it must pass the Makerfield test, providing tangible improvements to everyday life for people in his constituency.

What does the Makerfield test require?

It requires that the agreement provide tangible improvements to people’s everyday lives, referencing voters in Burnham’s Greater Manchester constituency.

Related stories